Contractual penalties of up to 210 pct of the rent are too high
In a judgement on 25th November 2016 (file no.: V CSK 123/16) the Supreme Court decided that a landlord may not impose on a tenant a contractual penalty amounting to 210 pct of the monthly rent, because such a fine is excessive and therefore in breach of Article 484 § 2 of the Civil Code.
The ruling was made on a case regarding the termination of a lease agreement of a restaurant premises. The parties decided that in the event of the failure of the tenant to return the premises after the termination of the lease agreement, the landlord would have the right to request the tenant pay a contractual penalty of 7 pct of the monthly rent for each day that the premises was not returned (which on a monthly basis amounts to 210 pct of the rent). After the tenant failed to pay the rent for an extended period of time, the landlord decided to terminate the contract. The tenant, however, failed to return the premises so the landlord demanded the tenant pay the contractual penalty.
The above ruling of the Supreme Court is significant when agreeing on a contractual penalty equivalent to two months of rent. The tenant may request the landlord lower such a contractual penalty and is worth landlords considering provisions for such lower contractual penalties since tenants may be able to reduce them anyway by legal means in the future.
An open door to redefining the commercial real estate market in Poland
An open door to redefining the commercial real estate market in Poland
The investment slowdown in the commercial real estate sector that we have been observing in Poland for over a year is primarily the result of the tightening of monetary policy arou ...
Walter Herz
The retail sector is not slowing down
The retail sector is not slowing down
The pandemic, conflict in Ukraine as well as inflation and high interest rates that recent years have brought have reshaped the real estate market around the world. The global slow ...
Walter Herz
Retail parks – current opportunities
Retail parks – current opportunities
Over the last few years, retail parks in Poland were mostly developed in smaller formats, around 5,000 sqm, either adding to the existing retail landscape or introducing modern ret ...
Avison Young